Tom Ramcigam (magicmarmot) wrote,
Tom Ramcigam

Blu-ray vs. HD-DVD

The HD-disc format wars look like they might be coming to an end. Warner has now switched over to Blu-Ray only, which makes 5 of the 7 majors doing exclusive Blu-ray HD content, i.e. no HD-DVD releases.

Considering that I use Vegas for HD editing, Sony now owns Vegas, and Sony is thoroughly attached to Blu-Ray, it seems as if I want to burn my own movies to disc for playback on a settop player, that Blu-Ray is the way to go.

Ah, but not so fast:
Currently no manufactured BD set top player will playback BD ROM material off of a BD-R/RE disk if it wasn't replicated at a replication facility, and does not contain AACS encryption. So, even if you can burn compatible HD .m2v streams onto a BD disk, they would only play on a PC drive with the correct SW emulation, but will not play on the set top player.
This is all dictated by the Blu-ray Assoc. specification. All BD player manufacturers must comply with this spec in its current form.

Okay, so all I really have to do is find some blu-ray authoring software that includes the features that will add the AACS encryption, yes?

Blu-print is now available for $50,000 per license. A free 30-day trial is available by request. Sony Creative Software also provides technical support and maintenance agreements for Blu-print at the Gold (6 months - $7,500) and Platinum levels (1 year - $10,000).


Gosh, it sure seems stupid for the Blu-ray association to force the AACS encryption if they want to actually sell players. I know I won't be buying one in the near future.

Apparently the Blu-ray Disc Association had just recently introduced the spec for playing back write-once BD-R discs as well as BD-REs. Philips plans to implement these new specs in its products sometime this year.

Looks like I'm still gonna be burning DVDs for a while, and if I wanna go HD, make the files available as some other playable format that can be downloaded or shown on a computer and displayed on a widescreen monitor. All I really need is an HDMI video card with HDCP, and I'm in bidness. Add a Blu-Ray-rom drive, and it becomes a set-top player with a hell of a lot more capability than any set-top player out there. Add an HD-DVD drive, and both formats are covered-- but if downloadable HD content becomes available, who really gives a rats ass?

Prices will come down eventually, just like they did with DVD burners and authoring software. In the meantime, I think I'll live.
Tags: darthcam, dvd authoring, filmmaking

  • (no subject)

    Four names that people call me: 1. Rob 2. Marmot 3. magicmarmot 4. Creepy Old Fuck Four jobs I have had: 1. fast food cashier 2.…

  • memeology

    1) What is your salad dressing of choice? Fat free ranch or Italian is a good standby. Asian Sesame is nice too. Balsamic vinegarette and feta…

  • (no subject)

    Rules: Copy to your own note, erase my answers, enter yours, and tag 10 people. You know who you are - we recognize our own. Also, feel free to add…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.